At a Glance
- Both quartz and granite are top-tier countertop materials that boost home value.
- Quartz edges out granite in most Florida homes thanks to its low maintenance, stain resistance, and modern look.
- Granite still appeals in luxury homes and outdoor kitchens due to its natural beauty and heat resistance.
- The better ROI depends on your local market, buyer expectations, and how the space is used.
Why Countertops Matter for ROI
Kitchen countertops are one of the most visible upgrades in any home. They anchor the space visually and functionally. When done right, a new countertop can be a major selling point, especially if you’re replacing laminate, tile, or outdated stone. But not all stone is created equal, and homeowners often ask: should I choose quartz or granite for the best return?
Quick Breakdown: Quartz vs. Granite
| Feature | Quartz | Granite |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Engineered stone (quartz + resin) | Natural stone |
| Maintenance | No sealing, easy to clean | Needs sealing every 1-2 years |
| Appearance | Uniform, modern look | Unique, natural variation |
| Heat Resistance | Moderate (avoid hot pans) | Excellent |
| Stain Resistance | Very high | Good if sealed |
| Price Range (FL avg) | $90–$150+/sq ft installed | $85–$140+/sq ft installed |
What Buyers Want For Countertops: Trends & Preferences
National design trends show a strong shift toward quartz: it’s being chosen more often by both designers and homeowners for its sleek look and hassle-free maintenance.
- 78% of kitchen pros expect quartz to dominate by 2026 (NKBA/Southern Living)
- Buyers like quartz’s consistency, modern aesthetic, and low-maintenance appeal
- Granite, while still desirable, is increasingly seen as a more traditional or niche choice
In Florida, the humidity adds extra weight to quartz’s non-porous advantage, it doesn’t stain, swell, or harbor mold like some granite can if left unsealed.
Which Countertop Is Better Maintained & has better Marketability
Granite needs periodic sealing to stay stain-resistant, which can deter buyers looking for a move-in-ready home. Quartz, on the other hand, requires virtually no upkeep. This “set-it-and-forget-it” appeal is especially strong in Florida markets where second homes, rentals, or snowbird properties are common.
Florida-Specific Countertop Insight
Local countertop installers in Clay & Duval report that quartz is preferred indoors due to its resilience and modern style, while granite is still favored for outdoor kitchens thanks to its superior UV and heat resistance. Starting costs for quartz in Jacksonville average around $90 per square foot, with granite starting slightly lower at about $85 per square foot.
While pricing varies by slab, edge detail, and layout, the long-term maintenance cost of granite often tips the scale in quartz’s favor for ROI.
When Granite Still Wins
- You’re targeting luxury buyers who expect natural stone
- You’re building or updating an outdoor kitchen
- You find a unique granite slab that fits the space perfectly
- You’re comfortable resealing the surface regularly or plan to live in the home long-term
Final Take: Go Quartz for ROI, Granite for Character
If your goal is maximum resale value, minimum hassle, and broad buyer appeal, quartz is the better investment in most Florida kitchens.
But don’t rule out granite. With the right slab and setting, granite still has wow-factor, especially in homes where heat resistance and natural texture are priorities.
FAQs
Is quartz really better for Florida homes than granite?
Yes. Florida’s humidity and mold risk make quartz’s non-porous surface a strong selling point. It also handles cleaning products and water exposure better.
Does quartz add more resale value than granite?
In many cases, yes—especially for mid-range homes. It signals “updated and low-maintenance” to buyers. That said, in luxury homes, high-end granite may still outperform.
Can I mix quartz and granite in the same home?
Absolutely. Use quartz in kitchens and baths, granite in outdoor spaces or as accent surfaces. Just keep colors and tones cohesive.
Which is more expensive to install in Jacksonville?
Quartz and granite are similarly priced, but quartz may cost slightly more per square foot. However, its maintenance savings often make it a better long-term value.
Key Takeaways & Next Steps
To choose the best countertop for value and lifestyle:
- Choose quartz for resale, durability, and a clean look
- Use granite when natural stone or heat resistance is a must
- Factor in Florida’s climate—moisture, heat, and UV exposure matter
- Get local quotes—Jacksonville prices vary by supplier and scope
- Don’t overspend on exotic slabs unless it fits your market
Looking for expert countertop guidance or a full kitchen remodel in Jacksonville? Contact KLC Floors and More – Florida’s trusted source for smart upgrades that pay off.
In North Florida and need flooring help?
Contact Florida’s flooring experts, KLC Floors and More, for any flooring questions, installations or flooring products.
